Type 1 Silver Eagles (1986 to 2021) carry John Mercanti's heraldic eagle on the reverse. Type 2 coins (from 2021 on) carry Emily Damstra's landing eagle with an oak branch and add a reeded-edge security variation. Both contain one troy ounce of .999 fine silver. For bulk buyers the silver is identical; the type matters mainly for 2021 coins, for collectors, and for how a buyer quotes a specific lot.
The short version
The American Silver Eagle has been the U.S. Mint's one-ounce silver bullion coin since 1986. In 2021, for the program's 35th anniversary, the Mint replaced the reverse design and refreshed the obverse. Collectors and dealers began calling the original coins Type 1 and the redesigned coins Type 2. The terms are hobby shorthand rather than official Mint product names, but you will see them on nearly every dealer listing that sells 2021 coins.
The bullion specifications did not change. According to the U.S. Mint, the bullion coin contains 1.000 troy ounce of 99.9% silver, weighs 31.103 grams, measures 40.60 mm across and carries a $1 face value. If you are buying Eagles purely for silver content, a Type 1 and a Type 2 coin hold the same metal.
How to tell Type 1 and Type 2 apart
You do not need a loupe to separate the two. The reverse is the giveaway, and the edge is a secondary check.
| Feature | Type 1 (1986 to 2021) | Type 2 (2021 onward) |
|---|---|---|
| Reverse design | Heraldic eagle with shield, holding an olive branch and arrows, by John Mercanti | Eagle approaching a landing with an oak branch in its talons, designed by Emily Damstra |
| Obverse | Adolph A. Weinman's Walking Liberty | Same Walking Liberty design, re-rendered in 2021 with Weinman's monogram added |
| Edge | Fully reeded | Reeded, with an intentional edge variation (a gap in the reeding) as a security feature |
| Silver content | 1 troy oz, .999 fine | 1 troy oz, .999 fine |
| Years you will see | 1986 through early 2021 | 2021 through current dates |
The year alone only settles the question for dates other than 2021. Every coin dated 2020 or earlier is Type 1. Every coin dated 2022 or later is Type 2. A 2021-dated coin can be either, so a 2021 lot always needs a reverse check.
Why 2021 is the tricky year
Because the changeover happened partway through the year, 2021 produced both types. That created a small but real pricing wrinkle. Some collectors want one of each 2021 type, and dealers sometimes list them as separate products. For a stacker, it means two practical things:
- If a listing says "2021 Silver Eagle" without a type, ask which one ships, or assume you cannot choose.
- If you are paying a higher price for a specific 2021 type, you are paying for collector interest, not for silver.
- When you sell, describe 2021 coins by type so the buyer quotes the right product.
Outside of 2021, the type distinction mostly collapses into the year. Dealers selling "random year" Eagles may ship any mix of dates and, therefore, any mix of types.
Does the type change resale value for bullion buyers?
For common-date bullion coins, dealers generally quote Silver Eagles as a group: one bid for "random year" or "common date" Eagles in decent condition. In that market, both types trade as one-ounce .999 coins with Silver Eagle recognition. What tends to move a bid more than the type is condition (milk spots, scratches, heavy toning), whether the coins are still in full mint tubes, and whether the buyer is quoting a specific year.
That is why the useful question is not "Is Type 2 better?" but "Is my buyer pricing these as generic Eagles or as specific dates?" If a buyer only offers a generic Eagle bid, a premium you paid for a particular type or year may not come back. See how dealer buyback prices are built before you pay up for any date-specific product.
Tubes and monster boxes
Bullion Silver Eagles leave the Mint in green plastic boxes that hold 500 coins in tubes of 20. That works out to 25 tubes per box. Dealers usually sell singles, full tubes of 20 and full boxes. When comparing a tube price across dealers, confirm the coin count; a "tube" of Eagles is 20 coins, while many other one-ounce coins ship in tubes of 25.
If you are pricing tubes against singles, compare the delivered cost per ounce rather than the per-tube figure. The silver tubes buying guide walks through that normalization, and the monster box checklist covers what to inspect on a sealed box.
How Eagles reach dealers
The U.S. Mint does not sell bullion Silver Eagles directly to the public; it distributes them through a network of large wholesale buyers, and retail customers buy from dealers. Proof and uncirculated collector versions are different products sold through the Mint's own catalog and are not the same as the bullion coin discussed here.
A worked comparison with hypothetical numbers
Suppose a dealer lists three Eagle products. The numbers below are invented for illustration only and are not quotes.
| Listing (hypothetical) | Premium over spot per coin | What you are paying for |
|---|---|---|
| Random year Silver Eagle | $A | One ounce of .999 silver with Eagle recognition |
| 2021 Type 1 Silver Eagle | $A + $X | The same silver plus a specific transition-year type |
| 2021 Type 2 Silver Eagle | $A + $Y | The same silver plus a specific first-year type |
If a generic buyer later bids every Eagle at the same level, the extra $X or $Y is the part you are likely to lose. That may be fine if you collect the type. It is a cost if you only wanted ounces. Run the comparison in fine ounces and delivered cost; the type is a preference, not a quantity of silver.
Which should a stacker buy?
For most bulk buyers, the honest answer is whichever delivers one-ounce .999 Eagles at the lowest total cost per ounce from a dealer you trust. Type 1 versus Type 2 matters if you collect, if you want a matched set for 2021, or if you prefer the look of one reverse over the other. It does not change the fine silver you own.
If Eagles are only one option you are weighing, it is also worth comparing them against other one-ounce sovereign coins and generic rounds. The rounds vs bars resale comparison explains why recognition can be worth something at exit, and the American Silver Eagle coin page covers premiums and buying formats in general terms.
Check more than one dealer shelf
A useful comparison starts with the same product size, quantity tier and payment method. The dealer review pages below are the stable jump-off points; current inventory and final checkout totals remain the source of truth.
Affiliate links on dealer pages may earn BulkSilver.co a commission without changing your price.
Use the existing BulkSilver tools
Frequently asked questions
Is a Type 2 Silver Eagle more silver than a Type 1?
No. Both contain one troy ounce of .999 fine silver and weigh 31.103 grams according to the U.S. Mint. The redesign changed the artwork and added an edge security feature, not the metal content.
How do I know if my 2021 Silver Eagle is Type 1 or Type 2?
Look at the reverse. A heraldic eagle with a shield, olive branch and arrows is Type 1. An eagle coming in to land with an oak branch is Type 2. Type 2 coins also have an intentional variation in the edge reeding.
Are Silver Eagles dated 2022 and later all Type 2?
Yes. Coins dated 2020 or earlier are Type 1, coins dated 2022 or later are Type 2, and only 2021 has both.
Do dealers pay more for Type 2 Silver Eagles?
For common-date bullion coins, dealers often bid Eagles as one product regardless of type. Specific dates or 2021 types may be quoted separately. Ask the buyer how they quote before assuming a premium will come back.
How many Silver Eagles are in a tube and a monster box?
Bullion Silver Eagles ship in tubes of 20 coins, and a full Mint box holds 500 coins, which is 25 tubes.