The Canadian Silver Maple Leaf is .9999 fine silver with radial-line and micro-engraved security features and ships in tubes of 25. The American Silver Eagle is .999 fine and ships in tubes of 20. Both hold one troy ounce of silver. In the U.S. the Eagle usually carries more recognition and often a higher premium; the Maple is often the lower-cost sovereign option. Compare delivered cost per ounce and how your likely buyer quotes each.
Side-by-side specifications
These figures come from the issuing mints: the U.S. Mint for the Eagle and the Royal Canadian Mint for the Maple. Both coins are legal tender issued by national governments, which is what makes them "sovereign" coins rather than private-mint rounds.
| Spec | American Silver Eagle | Canadian Silver Maple Leaf |
|---|---|---|
| Issuer | United States Mint | Royal Canadian Mint |
| First year | 1986 | 1988 |
| Fineness | .999 (99.9%) | .9999 (99.99%) |
| Weight | 31.103 g (1 troy oz) | 31.11 g (1 troy oz, stated as minimum guaranteed weight) |
| Diameter | 40.60 mm | 38 mm |
| Face value | $1 USD | $5 CAD |
| Edge | Reeded (Type 2 adds an edge variation) | Serrated |
| Standard tube | 20 coins | 25 coins |
| Standard mint box | 500 coins (25 tubes) | 500 coins (20 tubes) |
The diameter difference matters more than people expect. Eagle tubes and capsules will not fit Maples well, and vice versa. If you store coins outside their original tubes, buy holders sized for the specific coin.
Purity: does .999 vs .9999 matter?
The Maple is "four nines" fine and the Eagle is "three nines" fine. In ounces of silver, the difference is tiny because both coins are struck to contain one troy ounce of fine silver; the Eagle simply carries a hair more alloy to get there. You are not getting meaningfully more silver from a .9999 coin.
Where purity shows up is in the surface. Higher-purity silver is softer, which can make coins more prone to handling marks. Historically, .9999 coins were also associated with "milk spots," the white blemishes that can appear after striking. The surface conditions guide explains how spotting differs from ordinary toning.
Security features
The Royal Canadian Mint has layered several anti-counterfeiting features onto the Maple. According to the Mint, the coin carries:
- Radial lines, precision-machined lines that create a light-diffracting pattern on the coin's fields (introduced in 2014).
- A micro-engraved maple leaf privy on the reverse with the two-digit year visible under magnification.
- Bullion DNA, a laser micro-engraved die mark registered in a database, which the Mint applies to coins dated 2015 and later.
- MINTSHIELD surface protection, intended to reduce white spots, on coins dated 2018 and later.
The Silver Eagle's 2021 redesign added its own security element, an intentional variation in the edge reeding. Older Type 1 Eagles have no special anti-counterfeit features beyond their design detail and specifications. For a general method of checking any coin, see the silver testing and authentication guide.
Tube counts change the math
Because a Maple tube holds 25 coins and an Eagle tube holds 20, "price per tube" is not comparable. Always divide the delivered total by the number of ounces. A quick example with hypothetical figures:
| Hypothetical cart | Coins | Delivered total | Delivered cost per oz |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 tube of Eagles | 20 | $E | $E ÷ 20 |
| 1 tube of Maples | 25 | $M | $M ÷ 25 |
| 4 tubes of Maples vs 5 tubes of Eagles | 100 each | Compare directly | Same ounce count, cleanest comparison |
Matching ounce counts (for example 100 coins of each) is the simplest way to compare. The tube size explainer and the delivered cost comparison guide cover the rest of the checkout math.
Which fits which buyer?
The Eagle may fit better if
- You expect to sell to U.S. buyers who quote Eagles higher.
- You value the most familiar silver coin in the American market.
- You are building a set or prefer a specific design type.
The Maple may fit better if
- You want sovereign-coin recognition at a lower entry premium.
- You like the layered anti-counterfeit features on recent issues.
- You prefer tubes of 25 for simple 100-coin and 500-coin counts.
Many stackers hold both. A mixed position lets you sell whichever one a buyer is bidding more aggressively on that day. Keep each coin type in its own labeled tubes so a buyer can count and quote quickly.
Reading Eagle and Maple listings correctly
Dealer listings for both coins use the same handful of phrases, and each one tells you something about what will actually ship.
| Listing phrase | What it usually means | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Random year / date of our choice | The dealer picks the date from inventory | Whether older Maples (pre-2018, before MINTSHIELD) or 2021 Eagles of either type may ship |
| Specific year (for example 2026) | That date only, often at a higher premium | Whether a full tube ships in original mint packaging |
| BU (brilliant uncirculated) | Bullion-strike coins that never circulated | BU is not a guarantee of spot-free or mark-free surfaces |
| Abrasions / circulated / "as is" | Coins with handling marks or toning, often priced lower | Return policy and whether photos show the actual coins |
| Tube of 20 / tube of 25 | Full mint tube for Eagles (20) or Maples (25) | That the tube count matches the coin you are comparing |
Two listings can look identical at a glance and still be different products. A random-year "as is" Maple and a current-year BU Eagle are not the same purchase, so compare like with like before deciding which coin is cheaper.
Condition matters more for sovereign coins than for bars
With generic bars, a buyer mostly cares about weight, fineness and authenticity. With sovereign coins, buyers tend to look harder at surfaces because collectors and stackers alike pay for clean coins. Heavy milk spotting, scratches or rim dings can push a bid down even though the silver content is unchanged. Keeping coins in their original tubes and handling them by the edges protects the part of the premium that depends on appearance.
Check more than one dealer shelf
A useful comparison starts with the same product size, quantity tier and payment method. The dealer review pages below are the stable jump-off points; current inventory and final checkout totals remain the source of truth.
Affiliate links on dealer pages may earn BulkSilver.co a commission without changing your price.
Use the existing BulkSilver tools
Frequently asked questions
Is a Silver Maple Leaf purer than a Silver Eagle?
Yes. The Maple is .9999 fine and the Eagle is .999 fine. Both contain one troy ounce of fine silver, so the practical difference in silver content is negligible.
Why do Silver Eagles usually cost more than Maples?
In the U.S., Eagles are the most recognized silver bullion coin and demand tends to support a higher premium. Some of that premium can return at resale if your buyer also bids Eagles higher. Check current quotes rather than assuming.
How many Silver Maples are in a tube?
Royal Canadian Mint tubes hold 25 Silver Maple Leafs, and a standard mint box holds 500 coins in 20 tubes.
Do Silver Maples still get milk spots?
The Royal Canadian Mint says its MINTSHIELD surface protection, applied to coins dated 2018 and later, is intended to reduce white spots. Older Maples are more commonly associated with milk spots.
Can I fit Maples into Silver Eagle tubes?
Not well. The Eagle is 40.60 mm across and the Maple is 38 mm, so holders sized for one will be loose or tight for the other. Use tubes and capsules sized for the coin.